Image via Freepik

Hundreds of homes are affected, but many victims may have little to no legal recourse.

On 1 April 2025, a devastating gas pipeline explosion rocked Putra Heights, damaging over 227 homes, 365 vehicles, and disrupting operations for nearly 200 factories. While emergency response and cleanup are underway, the legal implications of this tragedy are only beginning to unfold, and they reveal serious gaps in Malaysia’s legal safety net.

Are Victims Protected by Insurance?

Image via Freepik

Emergency fire department help. Flame extinguishing process. Firefighters rescue victims from burning house. First aid. Fireman carrying kid. Medical urgency. Unconscious person. Garish vector concept

Many assume that insurance will cover the losses, but that isn’t always the case. For homes, fire insurance is usually required for mortgaged properties, but older, fully paid homes often lack this coverage. Even with insurance, policies often exclude personal valuables and high-tech devices like laptops or mobile phones. And perhaps most painfully, items of sentimental value are irreplaceable.

When it comes to vehicles, those with only third-party insurance, which is common for older cars and motorcycles will not be covered for fire damage. This leaves many victims with no financial recover options unless ex gratia aid is provided.

What About Business Loss?

Image via Freepik

Over 200 nearby factories were forced to pause operations after the explosion disrupted gas supply. However, in legal terms, these losses are classified as “pure economic loss”, financial damages not tied to direct physical injury or property damage.

Malaysia courts, including the 2018 **Federal Court decision in TNB v Batu Kemas **, have ruled that pure economic losses are not claimable, even when negligence is proven. This presents a troubling limitation for businesses affected by industrial disasters that weren’t directly damaged but still suffered financially.

Who Is Responsible?

This incident has turned the spotlight on three key entities:

• The pipeline owner (licensed gas transporter)
• The Energy Commission, under the Gas Supply Act 1993
• The local authority, under the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974

The pipeline owner is legally responsible for the maintenance and safety of gas infrastructure. The Energy Commission duties include protecting the public from gas-related dangers, while the local authority reportedly issued a permit for excavation works near the pipeline, possibly contributing to the accident.

However, statutory protection may prevent victims from suing public bodies. Under current law:

• The Energy Commission is shield by Section 37 of Act 501
• Local authorities are protected by Section 95(2) of Act 133, as confirmed in the Majlis Perbandaran Ampang Jaya v Steven Phoa case

This creates a situation where even if mistakes were made, legal accountability may be difficult to pursue.

A Call for Stronger Legal Protections

Image via Freepik

While the Federal and Selangor governments have provided ex gratia financial assistance, this should not distract from a bigger issue: Malaysia’s legal and insurance frameworks are not equipped to handle industrial-scale disasters.

We need reforms that include:

• Mandatory liability insurance for high-risk infrastructure projects
• Stronger protections for economic losses
• Clearer lines of accountability for public and private sector actors
• Closing insurance coverage gaps for homeowners and businesses alike

“The Putra Heights explosion is a wake up-call,” says Dr Wilson Tay Tze Vern, a law lecturer at Taylor’s University. “As Malaysia modernises, our legal systems must evolve too in order to protect lives, property, and economic stability.”

What You Can Do Now

Image via Freepik

Environmental pollution man-made disastrous problems orthogonal poster with household garbage piles and industrial waste vector illustration

• Check your insurance: Ensure your home, business, and vehicles have the right coverage, including fire and comprehensive plans.
• Push for policy change: Support efforts to update legal protections for industrial zones and infrastructure safety.
• Stay informed: Know your rights in the event of an industrial disaster.

Tragedies like Putra Heights should not leave victims unprotected. It’s time we align Malaysia’s legal landscape with the realities of our modern infrastructure and industrial growth.